Despite their widespread use in California, DUI field sobriety tests are notoriously flawed and unreliable.
1. What are Field Sobriety Tests?
Field sobriety tests (“FSTs”) are physical and mental exercises that help police determine whether to arrest you for California DUI. FSTs can also be used in court as evidence to prove you were driving impaired. But they are just one factor police, prosecutors and courts consider.
Failing one or more FSTs does not necessarily mean you will be found guilty of DUI.
2. The Standardized Field Sobriety Test
Of the many different field sobriety tests that exist, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) has standardized three. Collectively the three are known as the Standardized Field Sobriety Test (SFST).
The three tests in the SFST are:
- the horizontal gaze nystagmus test (HGN),
- the walk-and-turn test, and
- the one-leg stand test.
A brief explanation of each of these three tests is set forth below.
3. How Accurate are Field Sobriety Tests?
The NHTSA says that officers who administer the SFST can accurately tell when someone has a BAC of 0.08 or greater — 91% of the time… or so they claim.
But this percentage assumes that officers have received the proper training AND that test conditions are perfect. In reality, both these factors can vary greatly.
Remember — just because you fail one or more FSTs, it does not necessarily prove you are driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs.
4. Do I Have to Take Field Sobriety Tests?
There is no penalty in California for refusing to take a field sobriety test. Often when you are asked to take FSTs, the officer has already decided to arrest you. He/she is simply gathering evidence that a prosecutor can later use to prove you drove impaired.
If you are asked to take FSTs, it is recommended that you politely decline to do so.
5. I Wasn’t Driving Drunk – So Why Did I Fail My FSTs?
There are many reasons why people fail field sobriety tests. FSTs can be affected by your physical health, officer error, and adverse conditions.
A good DUI defense attorney knows the limitations of field sobriety tests and can often challenge the results.
Your Physical Condition Can Affect a Field Sobriety Test
Physical factors that might affect your performance on a field sobriety test include:
- Your age,
- The use of medications that do not impair driving, and
- Medical conditions (such as vertigo or foot pronation).
Officer Error Could Cause You to Fail an FST
The outcome of a field sobriety test can be affected by what the officer doesn’t know, or does or doesn’t do. Examples include:
- The officer has not received proper training in the particular FST, or
- The officer gives you vague instructions.
Adverse Conditions Can Lead to Field Sobriety Test Failures
You might have failed one or more FSTs due to adverse conditions such as:
- An uneven surface,
- Poor weather,
- Insufficient room to perform the test,
- Inadequate lighting,
- High noise levels, or
- Attire (such as high heels) that was unsuitable for the test.
6. The Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus Test (HGN)
The HGN is similar to a test you might experience when an optometrist tests your vision. The officer will ask you to follow an object — such as a pen or a small flashlight — left and right with just your eyes.
Drug- or alcohol-impaired people often have difficulty smoothly tracking a moving object. They exhibit “nystagmus” — fast, uncontrollable movements of the eyes — earlier than unimpaired people.
There are certain conditions besides being drunk, however, that can cause you to fail the HGN. They include:
- The use of anti-seizure medications (such as Dilantin),
- Inner ear disorders,
- Thiamine or vitamin B12 deficiency, and
- Diseases of the brain.
7. The Walk-and-Turn Test
The walk-and-turn test (“WAT”) is a “divided attention” test. It requires you to listen to and follow instructions while performing simple physical movements.
During the WAT, an officer will ask you to:
- Take nine heel-to-toe steps on a real or imaginary line,
- Pivot 180˚, and
- Take nine heel-to-toe steps back.
The officer will be watch you to see whether you lose your balance or show other signs of impairment.
8. The One-Leg Stand Test
The one-leg stand test (“OLS”) is another divided attention test. In the OLS, you will be asked to stand with one foot approximately six inches off the ground.
While you stand with a raised foot, you will be required to count out loud starting with one thousand — one thousand-one, one thousand-two, etc. The test will last for 30 seconds.
The officer will be looking for signs of intoxication. He/she may suspect you of DUI if you: ·
- sway while balancing,
- use your arms to keep your balance,
- hop to maintain your balance, or
- put down your foot.
9. Non-Standardized Field Sobriety Tests
In addition to the SFST, there are four “non-standardized” tests in common use by law enforcement. They are:
- The hand pat test,
- The finger-to-nose test,
- The Rhomberg Balance test (in which you are asked to close your eyes and estimate when 30 seconds has passed), and
- The finger count test (in which you touch your thumb to each of your fingers while counting them off forwards and backwards).
Remember — field sobriety tests are just one factor in a California DUI case. “Failing” them does not mean you will be convicted of DUI.
We represent clients throughout Los Angeles, Riverside, San Bernardino, Ventura and Orange Counties. Contact us for a free consultation if you or someone you know has been charged with DUI.